Children of a Lesser God

Captioned Print A Taming of the Shrew story with a different twist: the "shrew" is a deaf woman whose rebellion against received notions of disability, and the pain they will cause her, limits her more than the notions themselves. So Sarah Norman, fiercely aloof and a perennial "pain in the ass," must be tamed for her own good, and this may be the final sadness of Children of a Lesser God, a film that means to fight pity and sadness. Marlee Matlin, an actress who is hearing impaired, gives a performance of rare intensity as Sarah, a bright woman who has chosen to become a custodian in the school for the deaf she attended from childhood rather than face the myriad challenges of integrating with the hearing world. She has her own reasons; Matlin holds those reasons close to the chest, revealing them gradually, reluctantly, powerfully. (Her performance is a gesture against the screenplay that saddles Sarah with a heavy stereotype for deaf or blind women: the sexual victim/vamp). James Leeds (William Hurt), a language teacher in love with Sarah, attempts to draw her out of, and sometimes penetrate, her silent world and is continually rebuffed for his clumsiness: Sarah's claim that deafness is "not the opposite of hearing but a silence full of sound" challenges him to meet her on her own terms. But all good shrews must come to an end; the film is a search, often moving and intelligent, sometimes clumsy, for a common language for these lovers. (Nevertheless the director has Hurt painstakingly verbalizing Matlin's dialogue, presumably for the benefit of hearing audiences for whom the film was clearly designed; while a few prints were subtitled for hearing-impaired viewers, subtitles for both languages would have given Matlin's dramatically skilled signing the dignity it deserves and saved Hurt from the narrative abyss at the same time.)

This page may by only partially complete.