Men in War

There are still books that say Anthony Mann's Men in War was a “standard” Korean War picture-at the time, eggheads thought Bridge on the River Kwai was far more adult. Today, the Lean film is slow and stuffy with ideas, while the Mann is quite simply a shattering parable on combat as seen in time and space, and as a test case for the struggle between duty and belligerence. A platoon is cut off in Korea. Its officer, Robert Ryan, is decent, liberal, doing his best. But they meet a rogue sergeant, Aldo Ray, who is a natural warrior. Shot in black and white, with a sparse music score by the formidable Elmer Bernstein, and peopled by ideal supporting actors, Men in War is not just a great movie and a draining experience, but proof that a guy could spend his life taking studio assignments and end up fit to be compared with Stendhal or Hemingway. The thing to marvel at here is the calm.

This page may by only partially complete.